I have never really been an advocate for home schooling or even private school for that matter. I am still not convinced but I might be changing my mind. If I do change my mind it probably won't be for the reason most Christians might think.
A few weeks ago my daughter (who currently attends a Spanish immersion charter school) came home with a project related to a United Nations document about children's rights (she is 7). I don't much care for the U.N. and I still don't understand why the school is bothering with the U.N. I didn't have a problem with the information in the document itself, but I made my objections known for other reasons. I was also a little miffed because of the way in which a family tree project was described. The school expressed its desire to not make any kind of value statement about any particular family structure, but then proceeded to say that they affirm all family structures (that is a value statement). They did this in one sentence. I made my objections known regarding that issue as well. If you don't want to make a value statement, then don't make any statement.
That said I was still not considering home schooling or private school. My daughter loves Jesus and often talks to her friends about Christ. I don't want her to grow up in a stale environment where she does not have the opportunity to share Christ that she does in school. There is something healthy about being challenged in your belief's. I am not out to protect my daughter from what I think is clearly an non-biblical world view. It is up to my wife and I to help her discern what is of God and what is not. I take that job seriously. Her and I have frequent conversations about what she is learning in school, especially regarding social issues.
Still something happened this past week that caused me to question whether I should keep her in public school or not and it had nothing to do with the previous two items. I helped her with her math. I don't often help her with her homework. More often then not my wife does that. As I was helping her I quickly realized she didn't know how to do math. I know she is only 7, but it was not quadratic equations, converse angles, or tangents; it was subtraction. The chips cost $.69, you paid 3 quarters, how much change do you get. This is the exact problem that took 10 minutes to finish. It took so long because I thought (stupid me) the teacher would have taught the class subtraction so my daughter could do her homework.
My daughter is smart. She can read very well in both Spanish and English at 7 years old. She does very well on her spelling tests, she rarely gets any wrong. I spent about 25 minutes working with her on subtraction, how to borrow, and even a little bit of decimal points. She was able to do all of it with very little help by the time I was done. Needless to say, I was a little upset. Not with my daughter, with the education system. To my knowledge she has never been graded on her handwriting, her math, or her reading (other then the state standardized tests). I am new at being the parent of a grade schooler and I am still learning, but I am very disappointed. We could accomplish more then the school does all day in half the time at home. Currently the only thing keeping her in the public school system is the Spanish.
If there is a good reason to home school it is the quality of education. The spiritual side of things should be taught primarily by the parents no matter what school the kids attend. Sure the school might be able to help (depending on the school) and the church may be able to help, but that is the parents job. It is my opinion that parents can over protect their kids. Certainly they can under protect as well. I imagine the amount of protection needed depends on the individual kid. Still I have never been convinced that Christians schools foster love for God. They sometimes foster biblical knowledge, legalism, and negative attitudes toward anyone who disagrees with them. The kids who love God and go to Christian schools usually have parents who love God and have influenced the kids with their love. Private schools generally have higher academic standards as well.
I am
beginning to wonder if the public school experiment is a failure and we should just scrap the whole thing and go back to neighborhood schools. I don't know what the long term answer is, but I do know I am not willing to sacrifice my daughter to an education system that doesn't teach.